Mutual Fund Returns May Not Be As They Seem!


Arthur Levitt, during his tenure at the SEC, experienced many cases where the non-indexed mutual fund manager bought shares for their own accounts before the fund bought the shares. The fund's purchases drove up the price of the stocks and the fund manager's made a killing on the deal. This is called "front running," and is illegal under securities laws.

Mr. Levitt also witnessed instances where the funds would buy huge blocks to run up the stock price at the end of the financial reporting period. This made the fund look like it had a high profit when it did not. This makes the fund's performance look better than it really is.

The SEC brought enforcement cases against some of the largest and most respected companies during Mr. Levitt's tenure as SEC chairman. A mutual fund run by Van Kampen Investment Corp. for example, claimed in public advertisements that it had returned 62 percent in 1996. This information caused the fund-rating service Lipper Inc to report the mutual fund as the top performer in its class, a full 20% ahead of the second-best performing fund in the category.

But investors weren't told that the excellent returns of the Van Kampen fund were on tiny assets of $200,000.00 to $380,000.00. This is because it was really a so-called incubator fund operating on seed money until its portfolio manager could establish a track record for marketing purposes. Nor were investors told that more than half the returns came from investments in thirty-one hot IPOs. An IPO is an "Initial Public Offering" that occurs when a firm first offers its stock across a public exchange. Since the stock is new nobody knows how it will perform except insiders.

The fund only had to buy between 100 and 400 shares of each IPO to achieve a huge amplification of the returns. The 62% return unrealistically raised investor expectations and was unsustainable. When senior managers of Van Kampen decided to sell the fund to the public some 15,000 people invested $100,000,000.00 within six weeks. Van Kampen settled SEC charges that it had misled investors. What a bunch of con artists. The modern day mutual fund is like a remake of the movie "The Sting" where Paul Newman's character has been replaced by the fund manager!

A fund run by Dreyfus Corp., owned by Mellon Financial Corp., paid almost $3 million to settle, without admitting or denying guilt, similar charges of fraudulently luring investors with unsustainable returns. Its manager claimed returns of more than 80%, but failed to tell investors that the fund had received a disproportionate number of IPO shares that should have been allocated to other Dreyfus funds.

The fund industry should work less on image creation and more on making sure that it has done everything it can to safeguard investor's money and boost returns. The mutual fund industry has become a financial powerhouse over the past twenty years and only cares about how much money it can suck out of the public just as it was at the turn of the last century when they were called investment pools. Funds are glitzy marketing operations instead of stewards of other people's money. Don't put your trust in them unless they are fully indexed like the Vanguard 500 (VFINX).

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Dr. Scott Brown, Ph.D., a.k.a. "The Wallet Doctor", is a successful futures trader, real estate investor, and stock investor. Dr. Brown holds a Ph.D. in finance from the University of South Carolina. His 1998 articles in Technical Analysis of Stocks and Commodities were prophetic in predicting an impending stock market crash. He has helped many people become profitable investors by teaching them to look out over many years to spot stocks that are low and primed for rise in the new bull market. His second article met with approval by Dr. Bob Shiller of Yale University. Dr. Shiller is the economist that Alan Greenspan most highly regards who coined the term "Irrational Exuberance." In 1998 he shouted to the world to "get out" of the stock market but now he is shouting to everyone that it is time to "get in!" The Wallet Doctor is not only sought after for investment advice and coaching in stock investing but also in futures trading and real estate investing. Visit Dr. Brown's site at http://www.BonanzaBase.com or sign up for his investment tips at http://www.WalletDoctor.com







Related News



Investing in India: Now might be the time if you can find one - USA Today

Investing in India: Now might be the time if you can find one
USA Today -14 hours ago
Q: Is now a good time to invest in companies in India, since they're down this year? How do I find and evaluate mutual funds that invest in India? ...
Portfolio crown jewels in frontier marketsBangkok Post
all 10 news articles

Nothing about investing is easy now - Chicago Tribune

Nothing about investing is easy now
Chicago Tribune, United States -Jul 7, 2008
And, as is common in a bear market, even the best and brightest investing professionals are hard-pressed to read the near-term tea leaves for either the ...


It's worrisome that so many managers eschew own funds - Baltimore Sun

It's worrisome that so many managers eschew own funds
Baltimore Sun, United States -13 hours ago
In times like these, investors would like to take some comfort that they are investing like the pros. Indeed, it's comforting to know that the guy running ...

Ardour Solar Energy Index(SM) Returned -27.17 Percent Year-to-Date ... - FOXBusiness

Ardour Solar Energy Index(SM) Returned -27.17 Percent Year-to-Date ...
FOXBusiness -4 hours ago
KWT is subject to risks associated with the stock market, index tracking, sector investing, investing in small- or mid-cap companies, foreign investments, ...
Stowe Coal Index(SM) Gained 40.12 Percent Through JuneFOXBusiness
all 6 news articles

Plan Now Before It's Too Late - Motley Fool

Plan Now Before It's Too Late
Motley Fool -2 hours ago
If so, you're in grave danger of making a huge investing mistake, because you're missing the most important element of success in stocks: self-confidence. ...

Global Investing Roundups - Money Morning

Global Investing Roundups
Money Morning -21 hours ago
Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) said yesterday (Monday) that it would be willing to reopen talks to buy all or part of Yahoo! Inc. (YHOO), but only if a new Yahoo ...

Tom Golisano investing $5 million into a PAC - Capital News 9

News 10NBC

Tom Golisano investing $5 million into a PAC
Capital News 9, NY -4 hours ago
ALBANY, NY -- Upstate billionaire and former gubernatorial candidate Tom Golisano says he is investing $5 million of his own money into a political action ...
Tom Golisano makes announcementCapital News 9
all 34 news articles

The 10-ETF Portfolio - U.S. News & World Report

The 10-ETF Portfolio
U.S. News & World Report, DC -3 hours ago
According to Morningstar's Investing Classroom, single-fund portfolios have the highest standard deviation (a measure of volatility), which means these ...
Feel as if your funds have been left behind?USA Today
all 2 news articles

The Gulf: The argument for investing in its equity markets is ... - Telegraph.co.uk

Telegraph.co.uk

The Gulf: The argument for investing in its equity markets is ...
Telegraph.co.uk, United Kingdom -5 hours ago
As a consequence we believe equity markets in the region represent a compelling investment. At the core of this is a significant transfer of wealth from the ...

Investing For Inflation - Forbes

Investing For Inflation
Forbes, NY -5 hours ago
It is difficult to envision that they will forever continue to accept a negative return when investing in US debt. Adding fuel to higher long-term rates is ...